Intentional Teaching, a show about teaching in higher education

Peer and AI Review of Student Writing with Marit MacArthur and Anna Mills

• Derek Bruff • Episode 77

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 45:12

Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message.

Today on the podcast, we learn about one initiative that offers a path forward for AI and writing instruction. It’s called the PAIRR Project, where PAIRR stands for peer and AI review and reflection. This approach takes the well-established peer review pedagogy used in writing instruction and adds a layer of AI-generated feedback on student writing. PAIRR has been developed and tested by dozens of faculty at public colleges and universities in California, and I’m excited to have two of those faculty on the podcast today to tell us about it.

Marit MacArthur is a continuing lecturer in writing at the University of California at Davis and one of the principal investigators on the PAIRR Project. Anna Mills teaches writing at College of Marin, a community college, and brings her experience with open educational resources to the project. Marit and Anna and I talk about student voice, AI literacy, metacognition, the importance of prompt testing, linguistic justice, and more. 

Episode Resources

The PAIRR Packet, https://pairr.short.gy/packet

The PAIRR Project, https://writing.ucdavis.edu/pairr

Marit MacArthur’s faculty page

Anna Mills’ website

“Peer and AI Review + Reflection (PAIRR): A Human-Centered Approach to Formative Assessments,” Lisa Sperber, Marit MacArthur, Sophia Minnillo, Nicholas Stillman, and Carl Whithaus, Computers and Composition, June 2025

“Comparing the Quality of Human and ChatGPT Feedback of Students’ Writing,” Jacob Steiss et al, Learning and Instruction, June 2024

“What Past Education Technology Failures Can Teach Us about the Future of AI in Schools,” Justin Reich, The Conversation, October 2025

Support the show

Podcast Links:

Order The Norton Guide to AI-Aware Teaching by Annette Vee, Marc Watkins, and Derek Bruff.

Intentional Teaching is sponsored by UPCEA, the online and professional education association.

Subscribe to the Intentional Teaching newsletter: https://derekbruff.ck.page/subscribe

Support Intentional Teaching on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/intentionalteaching

Find me on LinkedIn and Bluesky.

See my website for my "Agile Learning" blog and information about having me speak at your campus or conference. 

People on this episode

Podcasts we love

Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.

Tea for Teaching Artwork

Tea for Teaching

John Kane and Rebecca Mushtare
Teaching in Higher Ed Artwork

Teaching in Higher Ed

Bonni Stachowiak
Dead Ideas in Teaching and Learning Artwork

Dead Ideas in Teaching and Learning

Columbia University Center for Teaching and Learning
My Robot Teacher Artwork

My Robot Teacher

myrobotteacher
Learning Curve Artwork

Learning Curve

Jeff Young
The American Birding Podcast Artwork

The American Birding Podcast

American Birding Association